64-year-old arrested over 1991 cold case murder

The 35-year mystery surrounding the disappearance and death of Cindy Wanner has finally reached a major turning point. On Monday, April 27, 2026, the Placer County Sheriff’s Office announced a breakthrough that true crime followers have awaited for decades: the arrest of 64-year-old James Lawhead Jr. 

For many in Northern California, the name Cindy Wanner evokes a chilling image from November 1991—a quiet home, an abandoned infant, and a trail that went cold for over a third of a century.

The Disappearance: A Mother Vanishes

On November 25, 1991, 35-year-old Cindy Wanner was at her sister’s home in Granite Bay, California. When her husband arrived at the residence later that day, he was met with a scene that would haunt the community for years.

  • The Scene: Cindy’s 11-month-old daughter was found crying, strapped into her high chair, completely alone.

  • Missing Clues: Cindy’s car, keys, shoes, and coat were all still at the house. There were no signs of a struggle.

  • The Discovery: Three weeks later, a hunter discovered Cindy’s body in a remote, wooded area near Foresthill, approximately 40 miles away. She had been strangled to death.

    Despite massive search efforts and hundreds of leads, the case eventually went cold, remaining one of Placer County’s most "heinous and notorious" unsolved mysteries.

The Breakthrough: DNA and Facial Recognition

The arrest of James Lawhead Jr. was not the result of a single tip, but a masterclass in modern forensic synergy. Authorities utilized advanced DNA analysis on evidence preserved since 1991, which finally provided a match to Lawhead.

However, finding Lawhead was another challenge. After a 2005 weapons charge, Lawhead had effectively vanished from public records.

The "Vincent Reynolds" Identity

Investigators discovered that Lawhead had been living under the alias Vincent Reynolds in Bullhead City, Arizona. The break came when the Scottsdale Police Department used facial recognition technology to match Lawhead’s decades-old booking photos with a current Arizona driver’s license.

When detectives raided his Arizona home, they found:
  • Multiple loaded firearms.

  • $15,000 in cash.

  • A "burner" phone.

  • A bag packed with clothes, suggesting he was prepared to flee at a moment's notice.

A Dark History: Who is James Lawhead Jr.?

The details of the suspect’s past add a layer of systemic frustration to the tragedy. At the time of the 1991 murder, Lawhead was 30 years old and had been out of prison for only 10 months.

He had previously served 11 years of a 19-year sentence for a brutal 1980 crime involving the beating of an elderly woman and the rape of her 11-year-old granddaughter. Despite being classified as a "mentally-disordered sex offender," he was released early—a point Placer County Sheriff Wayne Woo highlighted as a sign of a "broken" justice system.

An Alleged Accomplice

The investigation has also extended to Lawhead’s family. His 71-year-old sister, Terry Lawhead Steele, was arrested in South Carolina on charges of being an accessory. Authorities allege she provided her brother with a place to live and maintained communication with him for years, despite telling police she hadn't heard from him in decades.

What’s Next for the Case?

James Lawhead Jr. is currently awaiting extradition from Arizona to Placer County. He faces heavy charges, including:

  1. Murder: (with special circumstances of rape and kidnapping).

  2. Kidnapping: "This family has suffered in anguish for 35 years," said District Attorney Morgan Gire. "Cold cases are not forgotten cases—they remain urgent and personal."

As Lawhead prepares to face a judge, investigators are now looking into his movements over the last 20 years to determine if he may be linked to other unsolved crimes across the West Coast.

 

Comments

Wise Folks Popular Posts

Does Healthy Gums mean Healthy Teeth?

30 Minutes of Jogging vs. Walking: Which Is Better for Weight Loss?

Foods That May Help Boost Male Sexual Health

Does Sunscreen Block Vitamin D Production? The Truth Revealed

The A-List Edit: Celebrity Style Staples You Can Actually Afford